Arvas, Abdulhamit. "Racialized genders in the early modern world." Throughlines. www.throughlines.org/suite-content/racialized-genders-in-the-early-modern-world. [Date accessed].

Racialized genders in the early modern world

Studying the relationship between race, religion, and gender in the early modern period

Download the transcript
Abdulhamit Arvas
University of Pennsylvania

Understanding how the Europeans of the early modern period conceived of the gender binary—and how they connected gender plurality to racial and religious difference—can help us see how the rhetoric of difference continues to be mobilized today. As we read early modern texts, we might ask:  

  • What do representations of racially othered figures—such as the Jewish man, the Black man, the Black woman, the Muslim, the Turk, the circumcised man, the eunuch, or the Amazonian—reveal about racial, religious, and gender variance?  
  • Is Othello, the Black “Moor” of Venice, the same gender as the white Iago?  
  • Why and how does Captain Ward of A Christian Turned Turk change in terms of his masculine virility after he converts to Islam and gets circumcised?  
  • Does Viola’s desire to become a eunuch in Twelfth Night suggest a wish to transition into a new, distinct gender that is neither man nor boy?  

When we understand gender, racial, and religious difference as interlocking structures, we can begin to denaturalize the supposed ubiquity of biological race and the gender binary.

Further learning

Video

Sexualization of Islam in Turk plays

“Turk plays” used race, religion, and sexuality to construct and enforce difference portraying Muslims, Jews, and Black people as sexually deviant or unnatural. Studying these texts reveals how early modern depictions of sexuality and race intersected.

Abdulhamit Arvas
Syllabus

Othello and Othello and Othello

Beginning with the play’s earliest performance, we study Othello from various critical perspectives through close analysis of the play-text and adaptations on film and stage. For several weeks students read the text of the play slowly and closely, paying particular attention to Shakespeare’s use of language, metaphor, genre, and dramatic form.

Abdulhamit Arvas
Reading list

Teaching racialized genders

Early modern Turk plays, travel narratives, medical writings, and drama are rich sources of this history of racialization. This reading list compiled by Abdulhamit Arvas offers useful excerpts and critical analysis to include in your syllabus.

Abdulhamit Arvas

Recommended

Activity

One word essay

This assignment in Kim F. Hall's Shakespeare courses asks students to analyze a single word in early modern texts using a variety of primary sources.

Kim F. Hall
Video

Racial mixing in Titus Andronicus

Teaching Titus Andronicus can open up conversations about early modern English familiarity with race, racial difference, and mixed-race identity.

Kyle Grady
Video

Blackness and Shakespeare's sonnets

Shakespeare’s works at large, and early modern literature more broadly, all deal with constructions of race. Shakespeare’s sonnets are especially fruitful for considering how the languages of fairness and darkness are used in nuanced ways to develop particular understandings of race.

Kim F. Hall